Alberta West News: The objectification of reality in Western culture as compared to Indigenous culture

Saturday, June 21, 2025

The objectification of reality in Western culture as compared to Indigenous culture

The concept of objectification, particularly in the context of reality, differs significantly between Western and Indigenous cultures due to their distinct worldviews. These differences manifest in how each culture perceives and interacts with the world, including people, nature, and resources. Below, I explore the objectification of reality in Western culture compared to Indigenous culture, drawing on the provided search results.

Western Culture and Objectification of Reality

In Western culture, reality is often approached through a scientific, skeptical, and reductionist lens, emphasizing observable facts and a singular truth based on empirical evidence or legal frameworks1 23. This worldview tends to compartmentalize society and the natural world, viewing humans as separate from and dominant over nature15 As a result, reality is frequently objectified—broken down into discrete, hierarchical components where resources, land, and even people can be seen as objects to be controlled, exploited, or developed for human benefit1 2.

A key aspect of this objectification in Western culture is evident in social interactions and media, where individuals, particularly women, are often reduced to their physical attributes or functions, a process known as sexual objectification67. This reductionist perspective extends beyond individuals to broader societal constructs, where nature is viewed as a resource to be conquered and extracted, rather than a sacred entity24. Furthermore, Western philosophy often debates the nature of reality as something potentially constructed by mental and cultural factors, yet it prioritizes material and observable dimensions over spiritual or interconnected ones83. This focus can lead to a form of objectification where reality is stripped of holistic meaning and treated as a set of isolated, manipulable parts.

Indigenous Culture and Holistic Perception of Reality

In contrast, Indigenous cultures generally embrace a holistic and spiritually oriented worldview, where reality is seen as an interconnected web of relationships among people, objects, land, and the spiritual realm1 2 39. Truths are often considered multiple and dependent on individual experiences, rather than confined to a single, universal standard12. The land is viewed as sacred, given by a creator, and not merely a resource for exploitation1 2. Time is perceived as cyclical and non-linear, emphasizing balance and continuity across generations, rather than a linear progression focused on immediate or future gains13.

This perspective largely resists the objectification of reality as seen in Western culture. Instead of reducing elements of the world to mere objects, Indigenous worldviews prioritize relatedness and balance, viewing humans as equal parts of a vibrant, interconnected whole rather than at the top of a hierarchy4. However, when Indigenous representations or individuals are interpreted through a Western lens, they can be objectified or misunderstood, often reinforcing dominant cultural biases and stereotypes109. For instance, Native American women have historically been subject to objectification and dehumanization through colonial stereotypes, which differ from the internal cultural understanding of their roles and identities10.

Comparative Analysis

Aspect	Western Culture	Indigenous Culture
View of Reality	Reductionist, deterministic, and material-focused; reality often objectified into parts for analysis or use8 13.	Holistic, indivisible, and spiritually based; reality seen as interconnected and sacred1 23.
Relationship to Land	Land as a resource for development and extraction; objectified for human benefit1 2.	Land as sacred, given by a creator; not objectified but respected as part of the whole1 2.
Perception of People	Tendency to objectify individuals (e.g., sexual objectification of women) as parts rather than wholes67.	Emphasis on relatedness and community; less focus on objectification, though external Western views may impose it109.
Concept of Time	Linear and future-oriented, supporting a focus on immediate gains over long-term balance13.	Cyclical and expansive, considering past, present, and future generations in actions13.

Impacts of Objectification

The objectification of reality in Western culture can contribute to societal changes that undermine equality and respect, sometimes leading to extreme outcomes like genocide or mass violence, as seen in historical colonial contexts where Indigenous peoples were dehumanized11. Additionally, self-objectification—where individuals internalize external objectifying perspectives—can impair collective action among oppressed groups, further entrenching inequality11. In contrast, Indigenous resistance to objectifying reality, often through decolonization efforts, supports collective action and positive societal change by reclaiming holistic identities and relationships11.

In summary, Western culture's tendency to objectify reality through reductionist and hierarchical frameworks starkly contrasts with Indigenous culture's holistic and interconnected perception. These differing approaches shape not only how each culture interacts with the world but also how they address social and environmental challenges, with Western objectification often leading to exploitation and Indigenous perspectives fostering balance and respect.

Alberta West News

Welcome To Alberta West Online News

Blog Archive

About Me