Saturday, November 21, 2026

Greta Thunberg at COP 31

 


Greta Thunberg spoke at COP31 in Antalya, Turkey, on November 12, 2026—her first UN climate summit appearance since 2021. Her central message was that the climate crisis is being driven by political and economic systems that prioritize profit and power, and that people must organize rather than wait for governments to act.[reuters][nbcnews]

What she said

Thunberg’s most quoted line was: “The planet is not dying. It is being killed.” She said it was being killed by “the very same people often thought to come to our rescue,” adding that “no one is coming to our rescue.”[reuters][reuters]

She warned that the world is moving toward “more genocides and more ecocides,” with basic rights compromised and necessities becoming luxuries. She framed climate action as inseparable from human rights, saying that people—especially those with privilege—have a duty to stand up and defend everyone’s rights.[reuters][the-independent]

Her critique of COP31

On arriving November 10, Thunberg called the annual talks “hypocrisy,” arguing that host countries use the event to “whitewash themselves” while negotiations remain influenced by lobbyists representing destructive industries.[nbcnews]

She said political and economic systems had become “incompatible with human nature,” and urged leaders to prioritize people and the planet over profits and geopolitical power.[nbcnews][apnews]

Calls to action

  • Push for “real policy changes,” not only diplomatic statements.[apnews]
  • Protect people and the planet rather than sacrificing the global majority for the benefit of a wealthy few.[nbcnews]
  • Recognize the COP process as insufficient on its own; Thunberg said positive outcomes matter, but systemic action is needed to save what can still be saved.[nbcnews]
  • End energy shipments from Turkey to Israel, which she linked to the war in Gaza and described as enabling an “ecocide.”[the-independent][huffingtonpost]

Context

COP31 was taking place amid disputes over fossil fuels and climate finance, and negotiations entered overtime without a clear deal. Thunberg also described the conference as a “greenwashed circus,” reflecting her broader view that COP summits have become increasingly ineffective.[dw][dw][dw]

Her speech was delivered on the sidelines rather than in a formal negotiating session, and it combined climate advocacy with calls for Palestinian human rights and an end to energy transfers to Israel.[the-independent][huffingtonpost]


AI Bubble Economics

 

 The “AI bubble” question is best framed as a real technology buildout with potentially bubble-like financing and valuation dynamics in parts of the market. AI can be transformative while individual stocks, data centers, and startups still prove overpriced—just as happened in the internet era.[arxiv][cfr]

 
The core economic bet
AI investment rests on a simple proposition: enormous spending on chips, data centers, power, and models will eventually be repaid through higher productivity, enterprise adoption, and recurring software-like revenue. The problem is that the spending is immediate and capital-intensive, while the returns depend on demand, utilization, and pricing power that are still being tested.[arxiv][cfr]
The five largest U.S. hyperscalers were estimated to spend more than $800 billion in 2026 on data centers, chips, and related infrastructure—up 94% from 2025. That scale explains why AI is now a macroeconomic issue, not merely a technology-sector story.[cfr]

 
Why bubble risk is real
A financial bubble is not just “prices went up.” It is a price component that cannot be supported by plausible expected future cash flows, or a valuation sustained mainly by expectations of selling to a later buyer.[arxiv]
 

Several AI-market features fit that concern:
* Capex is outrunning monetization: Major tech companies are investing more than they currently earn back; Alphabet, Amazon, and Meta reported negative free cash flow in the third quarter.[cfr]
* Debt is becoming central: Alphabet, Amazon, Meta, and Microsoft collectively borrowed $214 billion in 2026 through late November, versus $83 billion in all of 2025.[cfr]
* Circular financing can flatter demand: AI firms are buying and selling infrastructure among themselves and lending against future purchase commitments, which can obscure true end-customer demand.[cfr]
* Winner-take-all incentives encourage overbuilding: Firms may invest aggressively not because each project is independently profitable, but because losing the platform race could be worse.[cfr]
* Valuations capitalize future gains: Investors may be pricing productivity and adoption that have not yet appeared in measured cash flows.[arxiv]

 

Why it may not be a classic bubble
The strongest counterargument is that AI is producing genuine revenue, real enterprise adoption, and measurable productivity effects in some settings. The leading semiconductor and cloud firms also have substantial cash flows, margins, and strategic positions—unlike many late-1990s internet startups.[arxiv][cfr] So the most defensible diagnosis is segmented: the infrastructure layer may be supported by real cash flows, while some private model companies, speculative data-center projects, and thinly monetized application firms may be materially overvalued.[arxiv]
 

What determines the outcome
The decisive variable is whether AI demand grows fast enough to justify the installed capital base. That means sustained enterprise spending, high utilization of data centers, durable pricing, and enough productivity gains to make AI adoption economically compelling.[arxiv][cfr]
The buildout also faces physical limits: electricity, land, water, grid interconnection, skilled construction labor, and imported advanced components. These constraints can slow investment—but they can also make scarce capacity more valuable if demand remains strong.[arxiv][cfr]

 

Macroeconomic consequences
If the AI boom continues, it supports GDP through construction, equipment purchases, employment, and wealth effects from rising equity portfolios. It has also helped support consumer spending through higher household wealth.[cfr]
If it corrects, the impact would depend on its speed and breadth:
* Gradual slowdown alongside rising revenue: Likely manageable; companies cut marginal projects, and the strongest infrastructure providers retain pricing power.[cfr]
* Abrupt credit and valuation shock: AI-linked equities, private valuations, data-center financing, and supplier orders could fall together, with knock-on effects for markets and investment.[cfr][npr]
* Productivity payoff still arrives: Even after a financial correction, useful AI capacity can remain in place and support future growth—similar to how internet infrastructure survived the dot-com crash.[arxiv]

 

The practical takeaway
The right question is not “Is AI real?” It is: Which parts of the AI value chain can convert capital expenditure into durable, risk-adjusted cash flow? A technology revolution can coexist with overinvestment, and a market correction would not mean AI disappears; it would mean that some investors paid too much, too early, for the right to participate in it.[arxiv][cfr]

Saturday, November 14, 2026

Is there a tendency for successful politicians to come from an entertainment or religious background?

Silhouette of a speaker and protestors. Vector illustration of the concept of freedom of speech, rights to protest and liberty Silhouette of a speaker and protestors. Vector illustration of the concept of freedom of speech, rights to protest and liberty politician crowd stock illustrations

Yes—there is a real tendency in both directions, but it is stronger and more systematic for religious/community networks than for entertainment backgrounds. Entertainment credentials can provide visibility, media skill, and fundraising access; religious involvement provides social networks, civic engagement, and voter trust. Neither guarantees political success.[1][2]

Entertainment background

A recognizable entertainment background can be an electoral advantage because it gives a candidate instant name recognition, comfort with cameras, a public persona, and often an existing donor or media network. Examples include Ronald Reagan, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Donald Trump, and Volodymyr Zelenskyy.[2][3][4]

But fame is not a reliable predictor of winning: many celebrity candidates lose, and experts note that name recognition must be paired with credible issue positions and campaign organization. The apparent “celebrity politician” pipeline is also partly a visibility effect: successful entertainment figures are simply more likely to be noticed when they run, while most successful politicians still come from conventional routes such as law, business, public service, and local politics.[5][6][2]

Religious background

Religious affiliation is more consistently linked to political representation, particularly in the United States. Religious communities tend to foster the civic participation, local networks, organizational experience, and fundraising connections that campaigns need.[1][5]

In Congress, Christians are overrepresented relative to their share of the U.S. population, and some denominations—such as Episcopalians—are especially overrepresented. That does not mean most politicians are clergy: ordained ministers make up only about 1% of the U.S. House, far behind lawyers, businesspeople, military veterans, and other common professional backgrounds.[7][5][1]

What “religious background” means

Form of religious connection

Political relevance

Personal faith or religious identity

Can build trust with religious voters, especially where faith is culturally salient. [1]

Active congregation membership

Provides social networks, volunteer mobilization, and community credibility. [1][5]

Clergy or ministry career

Offers public speaking and organizing skills, but is relatively uncommon among elected officials. [7]

Religious institutional ties

Can supply donors, endorsements, and campaign infrastructure; historically, some denominations have had disproportionate political influence. [1]


Bottom line

  • Entertainment background: A useful but uneven shortcut to attention; it helps some candidates stand out but does not reliably produce governing success or electoral victory.[6][2]
  • Religious background: More often a source of the underlying civic infrastructure—networks, engagement, trust, and resources—that supports political careers.[5][1]
  • The biggest predictor remains conventional political capital: education, professional status, community involvement, party support, money, and prior experience. Religious networks often help supply those assets; entertainment fame mainly supplies visibility.[6][5]

So, if by “successful politicians” you mean people who win office, entertainment backgrounds can help at the margins. If you mean the broader pathway into durable political power, religious and community networks appear to matter more systematically.[7][1]

⁂


How do lawyers compare as political candidates

Lawyers are among the strongest and most overrepresented groups among successful political candidates—especially in the United States. Their edge appears to come less from voters’ affection for lawyers than from early fundraising, professional networks, advocacy skills, and a higher propensity to run.[11][12]

Electoral advantage

Research finds that, conditional on running, lawyers win at about twice the rate of candidates from other backgrounds. In the 115th Congress, lawyers were only 0.4% of the voting-age population but held 39% of House seats and 56% of Senate seats.[11]

The key mechanism is money: non-incumbent lawyer candidates raise roughly twice as much as comparable non-lawyer candidates in the opening months of a campaign, largely through donations from other lawyers. Because early fundraising strongly shapes primary outcomes, that network advantage can translate into electoral success.[12][11]

Why lawyers do well

Advantage

How it helps a campaign

Professional networks

Lawyers can tap affluent, politically engaged peers for early donations and endorsements. [11][12]

Advocacy and persuasion

Legal training builds skills in argument, public speaking, research, and handling scrutiny. [13][14]

Institutional fluency

Familiarity with statutes, courts, regulation, and legislative process can make candidates credible on policy. [13]

Political inclination

Lawyers are much more likely than the general public to consider running; one comparison found they were 54 times more likely to run. [12]

Elite-school connections

Graduates of prominent law schools often have especially strong donor and professional networks. [12]


Important limits

A law degree is not itself a voter-facing asset. Political scientists and practitioners note that voters do not appear to reward candidates simply for having a legal background; lawyers’ advantage is mainly organizational and financial rather than a direct preference for “lawyer” as a credential.[14][11]

Legal training can even create campaign friction. Former Massachusetts Governor Deval Patrick described a mismatch between legal reasoning and political campaigning, while also crediting law with teaching rapid learning and adaptability. Campaign consultants similarly emphasize that community relationships, a clear message, and a base of support matter more than the J.D. itself.[13][14]

Compared with other backgrounds

Background

Typical political advantage

Lawyer

Strong early fundraising, networks, legal/policy fluency, and high likelihood of running. [11][12]

Entertainment figure

High name recognition and media comfort, but no guarantee of fundraising or campaign organization. [15]

Religious leader / active religious background

Community trust, volunteer networks, and mobilization; clergy themselves remain rare in Congress. [16]

Business leader

Fundraising capacity and management credentials, though less directly tied to legislative or legal expertise. [13][12]

Career political staffer

Campaign knowledge and party connections; this group has grown as lawyer-legislators have declined. [14]


Bottom line

Compared with entertainers or religious figures, lawyers are generally more systematically advantaged as candidates, particularly in U.S. primaries and legislative elections. Their advantage is not that voters especially want lawyers in office; it is that legal careers supply the money, networks, advocacy practice, and political self-selection that make campaigns competitive.[12][11]

⁂


  • https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2021/02/08/why-are-american-politicians-more-pious-than-their-constituents        
  • https://www.npr.org/sections/itsallpolitics/2014/02/05/272096521/celebrities-turn-star-power-toward-political-stage?ft=nprml&f=272096521    
  • https://berkeleypoliticalreview.org/2026/04/23/the-growing-trend-of-performance-driven-politics/ 
  • https://www.thenationalnews.com/arts-culture/television/2022/03/11/from-zelenskyy-to-trump-world-leaders-who-swapped-the-entertainment-industry-for-politics/ 
  • https://www.christiancentury.org/news/number-christians-overrepresented-congress      
  • https://www.krqe.com/news-resources/ranking/20-celebrities-who-became-politicians/   
  • https://theconversation.com/with-raphael-warnocks-reelection-congresss-club-of-pastor-politicians-holds-on-to-one-of-its-few-members-151258   
  • https://www.ncronline.org/news/though-religious-left-showed-midterms-not-everyone-sees-new-trend 
  • http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/talking_point/419415.stm 
  • https://berkeleyhighjacket.com/2024/entertainment/pop-culture-to-president-pipeline 
  • https://law-journals-books.vlex.com/vid/why-are-there-so-1049652920       
  • https://www.salon.com/2016/06/12/the_real_masters_of_the_universe_the_astounding_influence_lawyers_have_on_u_s_government_and_policy/        
  • https://law.stanford.edu/stanford-lawyer/articles/the-run-for-office-jds-in-politics/    
  • https://clp.law.harvard.edu/knowledge-hub/magazine/issues/lawyers-in-politics/lawyers-in-politics/    
  • https://www.npr.org/sections/itsallpolitics/2014/02/05/272096521/celebrities-turn-star-power-toward-political-stage?ft=nprml&f=272096521 
  • https://theconversation.com/with-raphael-warnocks-reelection-congresss-club-of-pastor-politicians-holds-on-to-one-of-its-few-members-151258 
  • https://jle.aals.org/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2914&context=home 
  • https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/japanese-journal-of-political-science/article/lawyers-and-law-graduates-in-parliaments-as-a-consequence-of-smd-electoral-systems-a-comparison-of-japan-south-korea-and-germany/E02993DE72A8E87E9E8C401FAD4027D3 
  • https://appext.hks.harvard.edu/publications/getFile.aspx?Id=1132 
  • https://clp.law.harvard.edu/knowledge-hub/magazine/issues/lawyers-in-politics/running-for-or-from-office/ 
  • https://digitalcommons.law.buffalo.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=4657&context=buffalolawreview 
  • https://clp.law.harvard.edu/knowledge-hub/magazine/issues/lawyers-in-politics/politics-outside-of-office/ 

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Message from Charles Aulds

Editor: Interesting statement. At that time Germany had been ravaged by the ongoing Great Depression that began in 1929 and Adolph Hitler had an audience ready for precisely that message.

German Nazi leader Adolf Hitler enjoys a quiet picnic between meetings, circa 1933. Picture 196 of a series of collectable images published in...

"In relation to the political decontamination of our public life, the government will embark upon a systematic campaign to restore the nations moral and material health. The whole educational system, theater, film, literature, the press and broadcasting — all these will be used as a means to this end."

___
Adolf Hitler (1889-1945), German Nazi Dictator
Source: Volkischer Beobachter, 23 March 1933
https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2012/03/harms_of_post-9.html

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Explain, in some depth, the Stoic philosophy

Stoic Images - Free Download on Magnific (formerly Freepik)

Stoicism is a philosophy of living well through good judgment, moral character, and responsible action—not through securing wealth, comfort, or other people’s approval. Its central claim is that a good life depends ultimately on how we think and act, rather than on whether circumstances turn out as we wish.[1][2]

Origins and purpose

Zeno of Citium founded Stoicism in Athens around 300 BCE; its name comes from the Stoa Poikile, the painted porch where the early Stoics taught. Chrysippus became its great system-builder, while its best-known later representatives include Seneca, Epictetus—a formerly enslaved teacher—and the Roman emperor Marcus Aurelius.[2]

Their guiding question was not simply “How can I feel calmer?” but “What makes a human life genuinely good?” Their answer concerned eudaimonia: flourishing, or living well as a whole, rather than enjoying a pleasant mood.[1]

Virtue is the true good

The most demanding Stoic doctrine is that virtue is both necessary and sufficient for a good life: neither success nor pleasure can make a corrupt life good, and adversity cannot by itself make a virtuous life bad. “Virtue” here means excellence of character and judgment, traditionally expressed through four interconnected qualities.[1]

  • Wisdom: Judging correctly what matters and how to act.[1]
  • Justice: Acting fairly and fulfilling our responsibilities toward others.[1]
  • Courage: Facing difficulty appropriately rather than letting fear determine our conduct.[1]
  • Temperance: Exercising moderation and self-command in desires and actions.[1]

This does not mean that health, money, friendship, or safety are worthless: Stoics classify many such things as preferred indifferents, worth pursuing but not what ultimately makes a person morally good or a life well lived. “Indifferent” is therefore a technical term, not an instruction to become indifferent to suffering; the distinction is between what has practical value and what has unconditional moral worth.[3][1]

For example, seeking financial security is compatible with Stoicism, but treating dishonesty as acceptable whenever it increases your income reverses the proper order of priorities.[1]

What is up to us

Stoic practice distinguishes our own judgments and choices from external events and outcomes that are not wholly ours to determine. The point is not that we can instantly control every thought or bodily reaction, but that our capacity to examine impressions and give or withhold assent is central to responsible agency.[2]

This changes the standard by which we evaluate action: deliberate intelligently and act well, without making your integrity depend on achieving the desired result. Preparing conscientiously for an interview, for instance, is your task; guaranteeing that the interviewer hires you is not.[3]

Acceptance is not passivity. The Stoics explicitly rejected the argument that, because events are fated, action is pointless: calling a doctor can be part of the causal process through which recovery occurs. Accepting that an illness exists is compatible with doing everything reasonable to treat it.[2]

Judgments and emotions

Stoic psychology gives a central role to assent: we receive an impression, then accept, reject, or suspend judgment about what it presents. An impression such as “I have been criticized” can become entangled with an additional judgment—“This is intolerable, and I must retaliate”—which helps explain why examining our interpretations matters.[2]

The Stoics understood destructive passions as involving mistaken evaluations, especially treating external things as if they were indispensable goods or catastrophic evils. Their ideal of apatheia means freedom from those disordered passions, not simply the modern everyday meaning of “apathy.”[3][1]

The aim is therefore deeper than concealing anger behind a calm face: it is to change the judgments that make anger seem justified or necessary. Still, the ancient ideal is demanding, and describing Stoicism merely as “keeping your emotions under control” misses its radical attempt to reform what we value.[3][1]

Living according to nature

The Stoic instruction to live “according to nature” does not mean obeying every impulse or retreating into the wilderness; it means living consistently with our nature as reasoning, social beings and with the larger order of the world. Reason should help us understand our circumstances, while our social nature gives us obligations beyond our personal comfort.[1]

Ancient Stoicism grounded this ethic in a distinctive cosmology: the universe is a living, rationally organized whole, permeated by logos, or divine reason. Its God is immanent within nature, not a separate creator standing outside the universe.[2]

The Stoics also held that events belong to an interconnected causal order, while maintaining that people remain responsible because their judgments and character genuinely help cause their actions. This combination of determinism and responsibility is an early form of what philosophers call compatibilism.[2]

A social philosophy

Stoicism is not simply a technique for protecting your private peace: justice and concern for others belong to its account of human flourishing. Its idea of oikeiƍsis describes the development of concern from ourselves toward others, while its cosmopolitan outlook treats human beings as belonging to a wider moral community.[3][1]

That means “I cannot guarantee success” is not a sufficient excuse for refusing to help someone or challenge wrongdoing. The Stoic task is to act responsibly within the situation, rather than demand certainty that responsible action will prevail.[3][2]

More than practical advice

Ancient Stoicism was an integrated philosophical system, not merely a collection of motivational sayings; it joined three fields of inquiry.[2]

  • Logic: How reasoning, knowledge, language, and sound judgment work.[2]
  • Physics: What the world is like, including causation, human psychology, and divinity.[2]
  • Ethics: How we should live in light of that understanding.[2]

These branches support one another: good action requires reliable judgment, and reliable judgment requires understanding the world in which we act. Modern presentations that retain Stoic exercises while dropping its cosmology are therefore adaptations of the ancient system, not its complete original form.[1][2]

Its difficult questions

Stoicism’s strength—making moral worth independent of luck—is also a major philosophical pressure point: is virtue really sufficient for flourishing under severe illness, deprivation, or bereavement? Aristotle’s contrasting position was that virtue matters enormously but a flourishing life also requires some external goods and favorable circumstances.[1]

Its account of emotion raises a related question: how much emotional suffering can be understood through judgments and values, and does freedom from destructive passion demand too much of ordinary human beings? These are reasons to engage Stoicism critically rather than reduce it either to an infallible life system or to the caricature of feeling nothing.[3][1]

⁂


  • https://iep.utm.edu/stoicism/                
  • https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/stoicism/             
  • https://www.rep.routledge.com/articles/thematic/stoicism/v-1       
  • https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2025/entries/stoicism/ 
  • https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2026/entries/stoicism/ 
  • https://www.britannica.com/topic/Stoicism 
  • https://www.britannica.com/facts/Stoicism 
  • https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2025/entries/stoicism/ 
  • https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2026/entries/stoicism/ 
  • https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2025/entries/stoicism/