Selenium Contamination of Water from Underground Coal Mining: Sources, Impacts, and Mitigation Strategies

Underground coal mining operations can release selenium into water systems, creating environmental challenges that persist long after mining activities cease. Selenium, a naturally occurring element essential in small amounts but toxic at higher concentrations, becomes problematic when mining activities expose selenium-bearing rocks to conditions that facilitate its mobilization into water systems. This report examines the sources, pathways, impacts, and potential solutions to selenium contamination specifically in the context of underground coal mining operations.

Selenium occurs naturally in the rock formations associated with coal deposits, particularly in sulfur-containing minerals. While open-pit mining operations are frequently associated with selenium contamination due to the large volumes of waste rock exposed at the surface, underground mining operations also contribute to this environmental challenge through specific pathways. When underground mining activities expose selenium-bearing rocks to air and water, oxidation processes can convert insoluble forms of selenium into more mobile selenite and selenate compounds.

The primary mechanism for selenium release in underground mining contexts involves the exposure of newly fractured rock surfaces to oxidizing conditions. As explained by researchers studying coal mining contamination, "Once exposed to air, [selenium] tends to oxidize into selenite or selenate. When selenite and selenate are exposed to water, these species of selenium will leach out from the rock"3. This process occurs not only in waste rock piles at the surface but also within the underground mine workings themselves, where newly exposed rock faces come into contact with mine water and air circulating through ventilation systems.

Underground coal mines frequently intersect aquifers, requiring dewatering operations to maintain safe working conditions. The water pumped from these operations often contains elevated selenium concentrations resulting from contact with freshly exposed coal seams and surrounding rocks. Additionally, abandoned underground mine workings can fill with water over time, creating reservoirs of selenium-contaminated water that may eventually discharge to surface water systems or contaminate groundwater. This phenomenon has been documented in historical mining sites where "periodic orange-water discharge events have been noted since the 1970s" from old mine entrances, indicating long-term contamination issues from abandoned underground operations8.

The environmental impacts of selenium contamination from underground coal mining can be severe and long-lasting. Government monitoring has established that natural background selenium concentrations in unaffected streams typically range from 0.4 to 1.25 μg/L (parts per billion)24. However, downstream of mining operations, these concentrations can increase dramatically, often exceeding regulatory guidelines designed to protect aquatic life.

Research in Alberta coal mines demonstrated that "selenium concentrations exceeded the Canadian and US-EPA water quality guidelines for the protection of freshwater aquatic life (i.e., 1 and 5 ug Se/L, respectively) in various streams and one end pit lake influenced by active coal mines"4. The contrast between affected and unaffected sites is striking, with studies finding that "background or upstream Se concentrations in water bodies draining the mines averaged 0.7 µg/L (N=56) compared with 9.1 µg/L (N=126) at downstream" locations4. These elevated concentrations can persist for decades after mining operations cease.

The ecological consequences of selenium contamination are particularly evident in aquatic ecosystems. At concentrations above safe thresholds, selenium bioaccumulates in the food chain and can cause reproductive failure and developmental abnormalities in fish, birds, and other egg-laying organisms. Scientists have documented that "selenium bioaccumulates in aquatic habitats and can be toxic to fish and wildlife at the concentrations observed" in mining-affected watersheds8. These impacts include malformations such as spinal deformities and missing gill plates in fish populations downstream of mining operations11. The element's ability to transfer from water to sediment to aquatic organisms makes it particularly problematic as a persistent environmental contaminant.

Human health implications also arise when selenium-contaminated water affects drinking water supplies. In the Elk Valley coal mining region, private wells on local farms and a municipal well were taken offline after showing selenium levels higher than 10 parts per billion, exceeding what is considered safe for human consumption1. This underscores the potential for mining-related selenium contamination to impact not only ecological systems but also human communities dependent on affected water resources.

Understanding how selenium moves through environmental systems is crucial for addressing contamination from underground coal mines. Selenium mobilized from underground workings can follow complex pathways through both surface water and groundwater systems, creating contamination patterns that extend far beyond the immediate mining area.

Groundwater represents a critical pathway for selenium transport from underground mines. As noted in one study, about "15% [of water] flowing (at an average speed of just over 300m/year) below the surface in cracks, pores and almost imperceptible gaps between minerals" creates a conduit for contaminant movement13. These shallow groundwaters interact with surface waters, allowing "surface water contaminants such as selenium to enter the deeper groundwater supply, which provides water to the wells of Elk Valley residents"13. This interaction between surface and subsurface water systems facilitates the spread of selenium contamination throughout watersheds.

The transport distance of selenium contamination can be remarkably extensive. A recent U.S. Geological Survey study documented that selenium from coal mining operations in British Columbia's Elk River Valley traveled more than 350 miles downstream into the Columbia River6. The researchers found "multiple lines of evidence that [selenium] from the Elk River Mines is transported [357 river miles] and may pose risks to aquatic life in the transboundary Columbia River"6. This long-range transport demonstrates that selenium contamination represents not only a local problem but potentially a regional or even international environmental challenge.

Seasonal variations also influence selenium concentrations in affected waterways. According to monitoring data, "the poorest water quality is usually seen between January and March when water levels in rivers and creeks tend to be at their lowest and mine contaminants aren't as diluted as they are later in the spring and summer"7. This temporal pattern creates periods of particularly elevated risk to aquatic ecosystems when selenium concentrations may spike well above already-concerning baseline levels.

Addressing selenium contamination from underground coal mining requires a combination of preventative measures and treatment technologies. Preventative approaches focus on minimizing the oxidation and mobilization of selenium, while treatment strategies aim to remove selenium from contaminated water before it enters environmental systems.

One fundamental preventative approach involves limiting the contact between water and selenium-bearing rocks. In underground mining contexts, this can include sealing abandoned mine workings to prevent water infiltration or submergence of selenium-containing materials in low-oxygen environments. As noted in research on contamination management, "Submerging tailings containing sulphide minerals, or 'subaqueous disposal', is practiced at metal mines. The low dissolved oxygen concentrations in the water overlying submerged tailings keeps oxidative rates at a minimum"4. This principle applies similarly to underground mining contexts where maintaining flooded conditions with minimal oxygen can reduce selenium mobilization.

For active underground mines, water management practices can help minimize selenium contamination. These include isolating clean water from potential contamination sources, treating mine water before discharge, and implementing recycling systems to reduce overall water usage and discharge volumes. The implementation of "comprehensive water management strategies that emphasize recycling and conservation" represents a critical approach to minimizing the environmental footprint of mining operations2.

When prevention alone is insufficient, various treatment technologies can remove selenium from contaminated water. These include physical methods such as ion-exchange and reverse osmosis, chemical approaches using ferric iron precipitation, and biological treatment systems that employ bacteria to convert soluble selenium forms to less mobile elemental selenium. In coal mining regions with selenium contamination, "Modern water treatment technologies employed in mining operations include ultrafiltration, reverse osmosis, and post-treatment water stabilization processes"2.

Biological treatment approaches have shown particular promise for selenium remediation. These systems "rely on bacteria to treat selenium and nitrate" and can take forms including engineered bioreactors and passive treatment wetlands5. One innovative approach called "saturated rock fill" uses existing mine infrastructure as a biological treatment system, where bacteria convert selenium to less mobile forms in a water-saturated environment2. This technology has been implemented at some coal mining operations with reported treatment efficiencies of up to 95% for selenium removal5.

Regulatory approaches to selenium contamination from underground coal mining vary considerably across jurisdictions, reflecting different priorities and environmental contexts. Most regulatory frameworks establish water quality guidelines or standards for selenium, typically ranging from 1 to 5 parts per billion to protect aquatic life. However, the enforcement of these standards and their application to mining operations varies significantly.

In British Columbia, the provincial water quality guidelines recommend selenium levels not exceed two parts per billion to protect aquatic life and 10 parts per billion in drinking water1. However, mining companies may receive site-specific variances that allow higher discharge concentrations. For instance, Teck Resources' coal mining operations in the Elk Valley have been permitted to discharge selenium at concentrations substantially higher than the provincial guidelines, with limits of 57 parts per billion for some monitoring locations7.

The economic costs of addressing selenium contamination from coal mining operations are substantial. A recent report on remediation costs for the Elk Valley coal mines estimated that "it will cost $6.4 billion to reverse rising selenium concentrations in Canadian and U.S. waters and operate those treatment systems for 60 years"15. This figure, which significantly exceeds the $1.9 billion that the mining company has allocated for reclamation security, highlights the potential financial burden that selenium contamination can place on companies, governments, and potentially taxpayers if adequate financial assurances are not established.

The financial implications of selenium contamination extend beyond direct remediation costs to include impacts on water supplies for communities and agriculture. When selenium contamination affects drinking water sources, communities may need to invest in alternative water supplies or treatment systems. For example, the City of Fernie, near the Elk Valley coal mines, "announced it would begin immediately exploring for a new secondary water supply" after selenium contamination rendered its backup water supply unusable13. These indirect costs further underscore the economic significance of addressing selenium contamination from mining operations.

Conclusion

Selenium contamination from underground coal mining represents a complex environmental challenge with far-reaching impacts on aquatic ecosystems, water resources, and potentially human health. While often overshadowed by the more visible environmental footprint of surface mining operations, underground coal mines contribute to selenium pollution through specific pathways including water-rock interactions in mine workings, dewatering operations, and long-term discharges from abandoned mines.

The persistence of selenium in environmental systems, its ability to bioaccumulate in food webs, and its potential to travel hundreds of miles downstream from source areas make it a particularly concerning pollutant. Documented impacts on fish reproduction and development, combined with potential risks to drinking water supplies, underscore the importance of effective prevention and remediation strategies.

Addressing selenium contamination requires integrated approaches that combine preventative measures to minimize selenium mobilization with treatment technologies capable of removing selenium from affected waters. These efforts must be supported by robust regulatory frameworks that establish appropriate standards, ensure adequate financial provisions for long-term remediation, and promote innovation in contamination prevention and treatment.

As demonstrated by the extensive contamination in regions like the Elk Valley and Alberta's coal mining areas, selenium pollution can persist for decades after mining operations cease, creating environmental legacies that require sustained attention and resources. Understanding the specific mechanisms of selenium contamination from underground coal mining provides the foundation for developing more effective strategies to prevent and remediate this significant environmental challenge.

Citations:

1. https://thenarwhal.ca/for-decades-b-c-failed-to-address-selenium-pollution-in-the-elk-valley-now-no-one-knows-how-to-stop-it/
2. https://elkriveralliance.ca/selenium/
3. https://wernerantweiler.ca/blog.php?item=2015-02-07
4. https://open.alberta.ca/dataset/456eee9c-86d5-46e6-bc2e-e605c6599eba/resource/b96ac61e-78db-4b2c-b0d5-40d9c0bf772e/download/3877073-2006-evaluation-treatment-options-reduce-water-borne-selenium.pdf
5. https://thenarwhal.ca/bc-teck-selenium-water-treatment/
6. https://montanafreepress.org/2024/08/19/study-finds-mining-related-pollution-350-miles-downstream-of-canadian-coal-mines/
7. https://thenarwhal.ca/bc-teck-resources-selenium-risks-study/
8. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/contamination-from-old-coal-mines-in-alberta-s-rockies-raises-cleanup-questions-1.7099909
9. https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.estlett.4c00222
10. https://www.canada.ca/content/dam/eccc/documents/pdf/npri-/academic-challenge/The%20Toxicity%20of%20Selenium%20and%20History%20of%20Emissions%20Controls%20from%20Conventional%20Coal%20Mining.pdf
11. https://e360.yale.edu/features/from-canadian-coal-mines-toxic-pollution-that-knows-no-borders
12. https://wildsight.ca/2024/03/19/the-elk-valleys-6-4-billion-pollution-problem/
13. https://wildsight.ca/2024/08/15/contamination-of-elk-valley-drinking-water-indicates-spread-of-selenium-pollution/
14. https://www.stalbertgazette.com/local-news/strip-mining-to-be-allowed-under-albertas-new-coal-rules-10015264
15. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/selenium-teck-coal-mine-toxic-pollution-1.7149181
16. https://esaa.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/RT2024-program-Abstracts-17.pdf
17. https://montanafreepress.org/2023/11/20/study-says-canadian-coal-mines-put-unparalleled-pollution-in-montana-bound-waters/
18. https://thenarwhal.ca/bc-elk-valley-pollution-study-launch/
19. https://www.canada.ca/en/environment-climate-change/services/evaluating-existing-substances/rm-approach-selenium.html
20. https://brownandcaldwell.com/2020/10/selenium-treatment-what-you-need-to-know-about-selection-and-control-advances-in-mining/
21. https://elkvalleycoal.com/mining-regulations-and-elk-river-selenium-pollution/
22. https://calgaryherald.com/opinion/columnists/opinion-coal-mine-pollution-could-put-southern-albertas-water-animals-and-food-industry-at-risk
23. https://research.fs.usda.gov/treesearch/download/33826.pdf
24. https://www.envirogen.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/ETI_Selenium_GrayPaper_V_FINAL.pdf
25. https://www2.gov.bc.ca/assets/gov/environment/air-land-water/water/waterquality/monitoring-water-quality/kootenay-wq-docs/wq_ko_elk_selenium.pdf
26. https://www.canadiancattlemen.ca/news/selenium-from-open-pit-coal-mining-may-pose-downstream-risk-to-ag/
27. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9379879/
28. https://www.ctvnews.ca/calgary/article/contamination-from-old-alberta-rockies-coal-mines-raises-cleanup-questions/
29. https://www.teck.com/media/2003-Water-selenium_status_report_2003-T3.2.3.2.1.pdf